Beth Marie's Old Fashioned Ice Cream Menu (Update 2025)
Welcome to Beth Marie's Old Fashioned Ice Cream, where nostalgia meets flavor in a cozy setting at 117 W Hickory St, Denton, TX. Here, you can indulge in a delightful array of homemade ice creams crafted with care and creativity.
Start your journey with a pint of their classic Cookies and Cream or savor the unique Texas Honey Whiskey, infused with raw honey and whiskey. For something whimsical, try the Valentine's Cookie, brimming with cream cheese-frosted cookies and sprinkles. The flavors are rich, varied, and sure to evoke joyful memories.
Complement your ice cream with charming toppings like vanilla waffle cone pieces or maraschino cherries. The atmosphere is warm, reflecting a classic 1950s America feel, perfect for families and ice cream enthusiasts alike. With friendly service and fast preparation, every visit promises a sweet experience that will leave you with a satisfied smile.
Ice Cream Flavors
Pint of Vanilla Ice Cream
Pint of Texas Honey Whiskey Ice Cream
Raw honey and Texas whiskey ice cream.
Pint of Old South Fudge Ice Cream
Chocolate, fudge swirl, and oreos.
Pint of Butter Pecan Ice Cream
Cream, butter and pecans.
Pint of Turtle Torture Ice Cream
Pint of Mint Chocolate Chip Ice Cream
Pint of Cupcake Ice Cream
Pint of Chocolate Ice Cream
Dutch chocolate treat.
Pint of Campfire S'mores Ice Cream
Pint of Cookies and Cream
Pint Bee's Nee's Ice Cream
Raw honey and lavender.
Pint of Chocolate Chip Ice Cream
Pint of Granny's Pumpkin Pie
Pumpkin pie filling with a blend of spices
Pint of Christmas Cookie
Sugar Cookie Ice Cream with Cream Cheese frosted Sugar Cookies with Red & Green Sprinkles.
Small Fun Pack
3 pints of ice cream, 2 cups of toppings, 5 cups and spoons, comic book from more fun comics, and an assorted bag of candy from Atomic candy. (Serves about 8 people).
Large Fun Pack
2 quarts of ice cream, 3 cups of toppings, 10 cups and spoons, A family game, and 2 comic books from more fun comics with 2 assorted bogs of candy from Atomic candy. (Serve about 10 people).
Build Your Own Root Beer Float
2 Bottles of Root Beer and your choice of a Pint of Ice Cream.
Pint of Valentine's Cookie
Sugar Cookie Ice Cream with Cream Cheese Frosted Sugar Cookies topped with Red and Pink Sprinkles
4 Pints & Free Koozie
Buy 4 Pints at regular price and get a Free 25th Anniversary Ice Cream Pint Koozie!
10 Piece Cherries
10 pieces of maraschino cherries
Pecans
2 oz. cup of chopped pecans.
Peanuts
2 oz. cup of chopped peanuts.
Sprinkles
2 oz. cup of sprinkles.
M&M's
5 oz. cup of m&m's.
Hot Fudge
5 oz. cup of hot fudge.
Chopped Oreo's
5 oz. cup of chopped oreos.
Pineapple Topping
5 oz. cup of pineapple topping.
Strawberry Topping
5 oz. cup of strawberry topping.
Vanilla Waffle Cone Pieces
5 oz. cup of vanilla waffle cone pieces.
Chocolate Waffle Cone Pieces
5 oz. chocolate waffle cone pieces.
Ice Cream Pint Koozie
Beth Marie's 25th Anniversary Ice Cream Pint Koozie. Perfect for keeping your favorite flavor nice and cold!