Beth Marie's Old Fashioned Ice Cream Menu (Update 2025)

  1. Home
  2. Menu
Ice Cream Flavors Sides

Ice Cream Flavors

Pint of Vanilla Ice Cream
$9.00

Pint of Texas Honey Whiskey Ice Cream

Raw honey and Texas whiskey ice cream.
$9.00

Pint of Old South Fudge Ice Cream

Chocolate, fudge swirl, and oreos.
$9.00

Pint of Butter Pecan Ice Cream

Cream, butter and pecans.
$9.00

Pint of Turtle Torture Ice Cream
$9.00

Pint of Mint Chocolate Chip Ice Cream
$9.00

Pint of Cupcake Ice Cream
$9.00

Pint of Chocolate Ice Cream

Dutch chocolate treat.
$9.00

Pint of Campfire S'mores Ice Cream
$9.00

Pint of Cookies and Cream
$9.00

Pint Bee's Nee's Ice Cream

Raw honey and lavender.
$9.00

Pint of Chocolate Chip Ice Cream
$9.00

Pint of Granny's Pumpkin Pie

Pumpkin pie filling with a blend of spices
$9.00

Pint of Christmas Cookie

Sugar Cookie Ice Cream with Cream Cheese frosted Sugar Cookies with Red & Green Sprinkles.
$9.00

Small Fun Pack

3 pints of ice cream, 2 cups of toppings, 5 cups and spoons, comic book from more fun comics, and an assorted bag of candy from Atomic candy. (Serves about 8 people).
$31.00

Large Fun Pack

2 quarts of ice cream, 3 cups of toppings, 10 cups and spoons, A family game, and 2 comic books from more fun comics with 2 assorted bogs of candy from Atomic candy. (Serve about 10 people).
$49.00

Build Your Own Root Beer Float

2 Bottles of Root Beer and your choice of a Pint of Ice Cream.
$12.00

Pint of Valentine's Cookie

Sugar Cookie Ice Cream with Cream Cheese Frosted Sugar Cookies topped with Red and Pink Sprinkles
$9.00

4 Pints & Free Koozie

Buy 4 Pints at regular price and get a Free 25th Anniversary Ice Cream Pint Koozie!
$36.00

10 Piece Cherries

10 pieces of maraschino cherries
$2.50

Pecans

2 oz. cup of chopped pecans.
$2.50

Peanuts

2 oz. cup of chopped peanuts.
$2.50

Sprinkles

2 oz. cup of sprinkles.
$2.50

M&M's

5 oz. cup of m&m's.
$2.50

Hot Fudge

5 oz. cup of hot fudge.
$2.50

Chopped Oreo's

5 oz. cup of chopped oreos.
$2.50

Pineapple Topping

5 oz. cup of pineapple topping.
$2.50

Strawberry Topping

5 oz. cup of strawberry topping.
$2.50

Vanilla Waffle Cone Pieces

5 oz. cup of vanilla waffle cone pieces.
$2.50

Chocolate Waffle Cone Pieces

5 oz. chocolate waffle cone pieces.
$2.50

Ice Cream Pint Koozie

Beth Marie's 25th Anniversary Ice Cream Pint Koozie. Perfect for keeping your favorite flavor nice and cold!
$8.00

Sides